Just as you get indecisive when you spend too long shopping in an outlet village, the world of second second opinions is no different.
Today I accompanied my father to a see a Bupa (Private Healthcare) Orthopedic surgeon for yet another opinion on my fathers pending knee operation. When I say pending, the actual date was supposed to be this Saturday the 29th with another private hospital based closer to my fathers house. Suffice to say, based on today’s information we are not going ahead with operation, well not with that particular surgeon and hospital anyway. All of this really depends on the outcome of the London Oncology Clinic appointment which we hope to get soon.
The world of Orthopedics and the measurement risk appears to be akin to holding ones figure in the air. Let me give you a quick rundown on what we have been told so far.
When asked about the risks associated with a total knee replacement surgery on someone of my fathers age, health and special cancer condition, each provided some interesting odds.
Chance of major infection?
NHS = Very high
Private Hospital = High but manageable through medication
Bupa = Normal patients would be 1% in my fathers case 2%
Chance of DVT Deep Vein Thrombosis?
NHS: 1 in 5 chance of pulmonary embolism and death on the operating table
Private Hospital: Management through blood thinning medication. 0.2% chance of death
Bupa: 5% but will be managed through medication and special DVT prevention methods/machines
What about my fathers Anaemia?
NHS: It would be the Anesthetists decision as to whether he/she would take the risk to go ahead with the procedure
Private Hospital: Raise hemoglobin levels through a blood transfusion of approximately 7 units of blood
Bupa: Blood transfusion required to raise hemoglobin levels to at least 10. Pointed out that 7 units was excessive and would result in further complications.
How long will it take my father to recover?
NHS: Up to 6 months
Private Hospital: 6 weeks for complete recovery
Bupa: 2 weeks to walk, up to 3 months to be 100%
To be frank, after this consultation I was rather disappointed to find that a lot of the information provided by the previous private orthopedic surgeon was contradicted by the Bupa surgeon. The Bupa surgeon made it clear that he would not operate on my father at the Bupa hospital, instead he would opt to operate ‘privately’ at the NHS hospital where he would have all the necessary experts at hand should complications arise. The private orthopedic surgeon had told as that it was ok to operate at the private hospital. The Bupa surgeon also said that the risks would be higher still if my father had gone through a round of chemotherapy prior to surgery. He suggested that my father could possibly begin chemotherapy approximately two weeks after surgery if required.
My father agrees that judging by the conflicting information it is wise to opt out and cancel the operation scheduled for this Saturday. Instead we will tentatively book with Bupa and ask the London Oncology Clinic whether it is wise to go ahead with this.
abdulazizuk Knee
Recent Comments